Red Cliff
Red Cliff II
B+
These two films tell a singular tale of two smaller armies uniting to battle a corrupt Prime Minister who seeks to rule all of China, and are basically director John Woo’s version of Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy minus the fantasy and set in third century China. A brilliant tactician and adviser clad all in white and highly in touch with nature, a reluctant ruler that must find his warrior spirit, three seemingly invincible warrior generals, a royal maiden that fights as fierce as most warriors, and a singular love story between the films’ main protagonist and his wife are all similarities any LotR fan would recognize.
Although these films have their own style apart from LotR and focus as much on the strategy and timing of the battles as they do the battles themselves. The battle scenes are long, but well shot so as to never quite become too tedious. Wire-fu is used sparsely as brief highlights for dramatic emphasis and is never the focus of a fight scene. Red Cliff I & II are near perfect examples of epic battle films, but they lack the character drama of Braveheart or Gladiator, have some weak CGI moments (most notably in the naval scenes in part II), and finishes a bit too open ended. Despite their few faults and however historically inaccurate these films may be, John Woo nevertheless manages to serve up over fours hours worth of well paced and engaging cinema.
Cashback
C+
I’d give this indie comedy a higher grade if all of its attempts to seem original didn’t come off as so familiar. This film is Clerks trying to disguise itself as American Beauty via a half lifted premise from Fight Club--insomniac art student and IKEA shopper who sees beauty in the everyday “stillness,” and naked women, takes on a nightshift as a supermarket flunky to put use to his new found free time. The director has an almost wafting approach to his style, but the film suffers mostly from the plodding pace and predictably dull progression of the plot.