Fuck a duck! I meant to click on Super Mario Galaxy but apparently clicked "New Super Mario" instead. WTF is that game eve? Anger bonerzzz!!!!!!111!
SMB3 was a close second, but that game is colored w/ the rosy glasses of nostalbia. SM Glaxy actually gave me hours of enjoyment as an adult. Outside of fap'n, there's not much else that can hold that claim.
I haven't played the new Super Mario game for the Wii, but I haven't heard good things about it...
The spin-off was no contest: Mario Kart. I prefer it on the Wii, but it rules in pretty much all its incarnations.
LY is right, the RPG was never my cup o' tea, but it's a pretty egregious omission, Jax. Fix dat, son!
See, pics of that (either in or out of your undies) would've clinched the hottest chick win for you. There's always next year.